What is the "Service analyst" role about? If it's very different from HR, then u need to think which one u would probably prefer more in the long term.

What do u hope to do in the long run?

I suspect in this case your interest, values and job fit are more impt than the pay, because u are not very experienced yet in terms of yrs of working exp (judging by your salary). This is the period whereby u still can test and see what industry/job u genuinely like and want to stay in the long run. No point going for the few hundred dollars more if it's not what u want to do eventually.