16-07-2011 10:06 PM | ||
undiscern | The above post is absolutely right, to a manager (most are non-phd), hiring a phd or doctorate graduate as subordinate is putting a threat under your own management. | |
16-07-2011 12:39 PM | ||
Unregistered |
Get a DBA or PHD only if u are going along the academia line, or like mentioned, R&D. The corporate world do not have a place for a DBA, despite what schools advertised. I have one and I had to hide it from my resume, coz I realise that it was the one that is causing me not being able to get jobs, as my headhunters found out from the hiring HRs, that no one in the management level who just have bachelor or masters will want to hire a DBA to be their staff. I only show my DBA when I am doing freelance consultancy work for firms, and that is only after 20yrs of solid experience that gets me the deals, and not my DBA. |
|
16-07-2011 11:36 AM | ||
undiscern | Strongly agreed with your last statement unlike bachelor or master where things are graded inhouse hence a good uni is impt. Phd or doctorate studies are peer reviewed by overseas uni. Most importantly is the number of quality publications (top international journals) you can achieve while doing your phd. There are many phd graduates from local uni whom graduated with none or only 1 journal paper. Even though local uni are top ranked, but these phd graduates will be forever laughing stocks of other more accomplished phd graduates whom may not be from top uni. | |
16-07-2011 12:36 AM | ||
Unregistered |
Quote:
However, if you are contemplating being a 'representative' of a firm, client-focused, client-rep type of role (sales, marketing), it can be impressive. For the same $, the client is getting "higher educated" staff/team. It boils down to follow-up and performance (Not doctorate) ultimately. Still, the fact is even Poly are getting more selective and employing more PhD as staff than before. 'Upsize' is the key word. Note: Generally at Doctorate level there is no such thing as 'bad' university, as the these/dissertation is "SUPPOSED" to be peer-reviewed. |
|
05-05-2011 12:37 AM | ||
Daniel |
Quote:
How about instead of a PhD, I pursue a DBA to enhance my current position in my current company? |
|
04-05-2011 12:02 AM | ||
Unregistered |
Exactly, like anything, it has risks and tradeoffs....U mite end up worse off or at the same place after 4 years...u mite also end up happier n more successful...but before u take up this ordeal: 1. ask urself, what u want to achieve after phd bcus most people only think it will make things better which is not necessary 2. do u have any interest in research, academia or teaching; or do u want to use it to enhance ur position in ur current area of expertize 3. better find out what kind of results do people achieve with phds in similar area in short, find out what u want n what u can get from a Phd....dont go with wrong notions or hype... |
|
03-05-2011 10:18 PM | ||
Daniel |
Bro so it is a double edge sword ? Quote:
|
|
03-05-2011 10:42 AM | ||
Unregistered |
Why detrimental ? Well, its not necessary. Depends on the case. It may be good, may not be good. May depend on field too. Companies only hire people when they need them. U will spend 4-5 years on a Ph.D. What skills will u learn that will benefit the company. Will they be better to hire someone with industrial experience or with a Ph.D. In my field, even tho I did not do great in my phd, I got an offer from an MNC abroad. But I could not find a good job in industry in Singapore. Academia or Postdoc are a long fight with low pay if u are not interested. So why is it the I could not get much success in Singapore . Bcus technology firms really dont do that kind of work hence dont need such people. U shd see if Singapore hires n needs Phd in ur area. If not , u will reduce ur chances of finding a job. Dont look at 1-2 PhDs in ur company. Look at what happens to most Phds from singapore. At the end, it depends on u. If u do well, u can get position abroad, u can go to academia, u mite become a teacher or professor. So, it all depends on ur determination. But if things dont work out as u plan, u mite also regret. A lot of Phds regret, some dont. Where do u see ur self ?? |
|
03-05-2011 01:07 AM | ||
Daniel | May I know why is it detrimental? Thanks for advise | |
02-05-2011 04:07 PM | ||
Unregistered | The earlier post is rite. unless u want a job which requires a phd, a phd wont help. infact it will be detrimental. if u think a phd will increase ur value in similar job market as u r in ritenow, u r mistaken. | |
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread. |