Treasury executive or compliance associate?

[inapickle]

Hi everyone,

I need some help making a decision. I have recently been offered a Treasury exec position in a small commodities trading company, and a compliance associate position in a foreign bank. The Treasury role is focused on payments and settlement/ maintaining and opening of bank accounts/ assisting traders with financing. The compliance role is your standard kyc/aml/due diligence checks.

My ultimate goal is to break into equity research (currently doing CFA Level II). I'm having difficulty deciding which offer to accept. The Treasury role seems more interesting as it's in the commodities industry, but it does seem like it could be quite administrative with settlements and account openings. The compliance job is within a bank, where I could do some networking and eventually transfer to a research role, but it is a 1-yr contract role with no job security.

Please give me your opinions on which position is more suitable!

Treasury v ops. I now doing treasury, everyday bout rates, bonds, fx, mm.
Compliance to me is like a lot of checking work to be done. Both role got a lot of corporate actions to be done. Choose the one that gives u experience closer to ur goal lor. Treasury at least u get to learn how company can move money around to re-invest to earn interest.

Originally Posted by inapickle

Hi everyone,

I need some help making a decision. I have recently been offered a Treasury exec position in a small commodities trading company, and a compliance associate position in a foreign bank. The Treasury role is focused on payments and settlement/ maintaining and opening of bank accounts/ assisting traders with financing. The compliance role is your standard kyc/aml/due diligence checks.

My ultimate goal is to break into equity research (currently doing CFA Level II). I'm having difficulty deciding which offer to accept. The Treasury role seems more interesting as it's in the commodities industry, but it does seem like it could be quite administrative with settlements and account openings. The compliance job is within a bank, where I could do some networking and eventually transfer to a research role, but it is a 1-yr contract role with no job security.

Please give me your opinions on which position is more suitable!

Neither of the 2 jobs help in becoming a stock analyst. CFA isn't going to help much as everyone is getting it, so that's like basic cert at best.

Originally Posted by Unregistered

Neither of the 2 jobs help in becoming a stock analyst. CFA isn't going to help much as everyone is getting it, so that's like basic cert at best.

What he say.
You can flush your CFA down the toilet for either of this two positions.

[inapickle]

I understand both positions are not relevant to my goal, but job opportunities are hard to come by.

If I had to accept one regardless, would my best bet be the Treasury position or compliance? Do people usually return to banks after working in a commodity firm?

Originally Posted by Unregistered

Treasury v ops. I now doing treasury, everyday bout rates, bonds, fx, mm.
Compliance to me is like a lot of checking work to be done. Both role got a lot of corporate actions to be done. Choose the one that gives u experience closer to ur goal lor. Treasury at least u get to learn how company can move money around to re-invest to earn interest.

could you elaborate more for a job scope in treasury? is it client facing?

Originally Posted by inapickle

I understand both positions are not relevant to my goal, but job opportunities are hard to come by.

If I had to accept one regardless, would my best bet be the Treasury position or compliance? Do people usually return to banks after working in a commodity firm?

The hard truth is both options don't have much to do with becoming a stock analyst. That's like asking whether procurement or marketing is better to become a civil engineer in the future. Answer is none.

Just pick the job you think is more tolerable. Don't kid yourself any of them or that CFA cert you are studying helps in anyway. Hard truth.

sorry hijack this thread. Would like to ask which would have a better long term job prospect/resume. A financial analyst in the government ministry or a compliance executive in an insurance firm. what are the options available 3-5yrs down the road.

[QUOTE=Unregistered;77737]could you elaborate more for a job scope in treasury? is it client facing?[/

You need to find out does your treasury role includes processing settlements ? Cos settlements very troublesome. My one is in corporate treasury. I don't really enjoy cos everyday have to churn bank instruction letters during lunch hour, and then chasing for authorised signatories to approve the fund transfers. And then the letter needs to reach the bank by 4pm. Too operational I don't intend stay long cos this ops role don't suit my personality. I like to talk to people than doing paperwork. but it could be possiblity to transfer dept. Why don't u go join MA Programme?

Originally Posted by inapickle

Hi everyone,

I need some help making a decision. I have recently been offered a Treasury exec position in a small commodities trading company, and a compliance associate position in a foreign bank. The Treasury role is focused on payments and settlement/ maintaining and opening of bank accounts/ assisting traders with financing. The compliance role is your standard kyc/aml/due diligence checks.

My ultimate goal is to break into equity research (currently doing CFA Level II). I'm having difficulty deciding which offer to accept. The Treasury role seems more interesting as it's in the commodities industry, but it does seem like it could be quite administrative with settlements and account openings. The compliance job is within a bank, where I could do some networking and eventually transfer to a research role, but it is a 1-yr contract role with no job security.

Please give me your opinions on which position is more suitable!

If you stay true to your ultimate goal... I would say go work for a brokerage (vickers,kim-eng etc). They take in an army of brokers every year from all sorta background.

Just so you know, most banks are shrinking their research team but I assumed you done your due diligence in picking this path.